User Experience Evaluation – CHI Workshop

After hearing that a bunch of my cool classmates have sent in position papers for CHI workshops, I decided that I too want to try to get a paper in to a workshop. Plus, I figured I could take advantage of Jeff’s class to help me pre-write this paper. After looking through the list of possible workshops at CHI I decided that the workshop about user experience evaluation methods best suited my interests.

One question in the workshop that I found particularly interesting is:

What are the requirements to UX evaluation methods in product development, taking into account not only the pragmatic but especially the hedonic aspects?

I found this question very interesting, especially the part about hedonism. The majority of methods in HCI are focused on people’s tasks and user goals. In HCI have some great methods for evaluating usability, but how do we evaluate pleasure?

I find this question very difficult. My initial thought is that it is less about evaluation and more about understanding humans holistically before creating the design. This holistic understanding then leads to concepts, which can be qualitatively evaluated using experience prototyping.

That’s about all I have for now, and I think 4 sentences is a bit short for a position paper. Do any of you have ideas? What I have just stated is obviously a very phenomenological approach; does anyone see how structuralism can be used to evaluate experience? Does anyone want to write this short paper with me?


  1. Gimhyewon

    Do you have any idea to construct UX too? I have on idea about your queations but I guess we are composing and decomposing UX at the same time.

  2. chmbrigg

    I think that Dewey’s concepts doing and undergoing as constitutive of the aesthetics of experience might be a convenient place to start in terms of a structural analysis.

  3. davidroyer

    Yeah, I agree Christian. I was also thinking of Heidegger’s concepts of Present-at-Hand and Ready-at-Hand.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s